What People (Mistakenly) Believe About How Memory Works:

jtotheizzoe:

Two psychologists recently embarked on a phone and internet survey of the American public’s beliefs about how memory works.

They compared popular beliefs about the intricacies of our memory with the opinions of experts, and found that people hold on to some dangerously wrongheaded ideas about memory, especially as it relates to criminal testimony. Many of these incorrect ideas are the result of memory science being twisted in media and movies (like The Mentalist or The Bourne Identity)

The widely-held misconceptions:

  • People with amnesia can’t remember their name or identity (They usually can).
  • A single piece of eyewitness testimony is reliable enough to convict someone of a crime (It shouldn’t be, eyewitness testimony is historically unreliable)
  • Human memory works like a camera, passively recording our surroundings, and you can recall additional levels of detail later (It doesn’t work like that, memories are subject to our attention spans and mental focus)
  • Once you form a memory, it exists on a mental “hard drive”, and you recall it as it happened (Memories are not written in stone, they change each time we recall them in the future and are under the influence of other memories)
  • Hypnosis can help witnesses recall more accurate details of crimes (It can’t, it can only help people be more forthcoming in answering, not make them more accurate)
  • People usually notice when something unexpected enters their field of view, even when distracted (They don’t, memory is deeply tied to active attention, just ask anyone who has failed the gorilla test)

Check out the paper here. Learn more about selective and imperfect memory and check out lots of example videos on The Invisible Gorilla website.

Recent comments

Blog comments powered by Disqus

Notes

  1. lifeasjackie reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  2. nuclearwinterwonderlands reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  3. bohemianarthouse reblogged this from nolackofloquaciousness
  4. latinaspitfire reblogged this from brooklynmutt
  5. anythingrelevantanduseful reblogged this from logicalmania
  6. med-nix-ine reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  7. midgetmonkey reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  8. khirnari reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  9. noneedtofeelthissorrow reblogged this from duties
  10. peripheric reblogged this from brooklynmutt
  11. jamilasays reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  12. jabberwockians reblogged this from queanofbones
  13. singing-songs-from-the-balcony reblogged this from mariuscreb
  14. anthrocentric reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  15. deansasstiel reblogged this from itsdetachable
  16. itsdetachable reblogged this from the-wolfbats
  17. rousse reblogged this from bookwormbreakfast and added:
    I knew all but the first and the second to last from classes. And the testimony thing seriously freaked me out too when...
  18. supercuddlypuppies reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  19. bookwormbreakfast reblogged this from brooklynmutt and added:
    Man, this would be your everyday laugh-at-how-wrong-people-are-about-science post except that the implications for...
  20. mariuscreb reblogged this from nocakeno and added:
    TRUTH For the record, I passed the gorilla test. Hideki and I were the only ones in Experimental Psych that year who...
  21. logicalmania reblogged this from kahtiihma
  22. revcleo reblogged this from kahtiihma
  23. myresin reblogged this from nocakeno
  24. kahtiihma reblogged this from nocakeno
  25. nocakeno reblogged this from evelark and added:
    Human memory is frighteningly malleable.
  26. evelark reblogged this from monsieurbombardier